still iffy....!

I still think anyone could obnoxiously come up with an object that contains all the same parts as, say, that magic marker. Then this object would still contain all the parts of "P", but would not, in fact, be "P." I am by no means condoning or encouraging this practice, I am merely stating that it is possible. Then I read Molly's post, and that all makes sense, too, so I am still unsure as to what I think, but I had to post because I haven't yet, and when I do figure out what I REALLY think I'll let y'all know!